Which approach to counseling is often more productive for inexperienced Marines?

The directive approach to counseling is often more productive for inexperienced Marines because it provides clear guidance and structure. In this approach, the counselor takes a more active role in leading the conversation and directing the focus on specific issues that need to be addressed. For Marines who may lack experience or confidence, having a clear path laid out can help them understand what is expected of them and what steps they need to take to improve their performance or resolve their issues.

This method is particularly beneficial for those who may not yet have the tools or knowledge to navigate their challenges independently. By offering specific advice and recommendations, the counselor ensures the inexperienced Marine feels supported and not overwhelmed. The direct feedback and structured nature of this approach can facilitate learning and motivate the Marine to actively engage with the information being presented.

In contrast, while non-directive and collaborative approaches encourage exploration and agency, they may not offer the active guidance that inexperienced Marines need. A combined approach, although potentially beneficial, may lack the focused direction required for someone still developing their skills and understanding of their role. Therefore, the directive approach stands out as most effective in fostering the growth of inexperienced Marines.